EthicsMMI & panel interview

Marianne has ESRD (End-Stage Renal Disease) and direly needs a transplant. She says that she does not wish to have a transplant, but her husband insists that she gets one and tells you that "she'll thank me for making this decision for her." What will you do?

238-word sample answer3 ways to stand out2 pitfalls1 follow-up

What the interviewer is looking for

Have a conversation with both Marianne and the husband to inform them about the treatment and encourage necessary medical treatment while respecting patient autonomy to meet the patient's goals.

Sample answer

End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) is a serious and potentially fatal condition that necessitates immediate medical attention, including the possibility of a kidney transplant. The decision to undergo a transplant or any other medical treatment, on the other hand, should ultimately be made by the patient, with the support and guidance of their healthcare team.

In this situation, it is critical to respect Marianne's autonomy and right to make healthcare decisions for herself. Even if her husband believes that a…

159 more words in the full answer Read the full answer

How to stand out

  • Talk about assessing the patient's competency to make informed medical decisions, and how your response could change if you concluded the patient was not competent
  • + 2 more tips in the full answer

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Do not jump to taking her husband's word and not respecting Marianne's decision to refuse treatment
  • + 1 more pitfall in the full answer

Likely follow-up questions

  1. How does 'Caregiver Burden' or 'anticipatory grief' cloud a family member’s ability to act as a surrogate decision-maker?

Interviewers often push further once you answer. Sample answers to each follow-up are in the question bank.

More ethics questions

Browse all medical school interview questions →

Walk into your interview having practised all 627.

Sample answers to every one, follow-up answers and ways to stand out, across the main bank and 51 health policy and topic banks.

Get full access