EthicsMMI & panel interview

Your hospital system decides to sell de-identified patient data to a large pharmaceutical company to fund a new wing for underserved pediatric care. Some patients feel this is a violation of the "sacred" doctor-patient trust. Do the ends justify the means?

308-word sample answer2 ways to stand out3 pitfalls1 follow-up

What the interviewer is looking for

Discuss that while utilitarian benefits to the community are significant, the ethical legitimacy of the project depends entirely on proactive transparency and the preservation of patient autonomy through "opt-out" or "opt-in" mechanisms.

Sample answer

This is a difficult ethical question because it puts two important values against each other: one is patient trust, and the other is helping vulnerable children get better care. On the positive side, the new pediatric wing could mean more beds, shorter wait times, and better care for children who may otherwise be left behind. Many people would agree that helping underserved kids is a strong moral reason. If patient data is truly de-identified…

234 more words in the full answer Read the full answer

How to stand out

  • Discuss opt-out options
  • + 1 more tip in the full answer

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Assuming all patients would agree if outcomes are good
  • + 2 more pitfalls in the full answer

Likely follow-up questions

  1. Who truly “owns” medical data - the patient, the physician, or society?

Interviewers often push further once you answer. Sample answers to each follow-up are in the question bank.

More ethics questions

Browse all medical school interview questions →

Walk into your interview having practised all 627.

Sample answers to every one, follow-up answers and ways to stand out, across the main bank and 51 health policy and topic banks.

Get full access