EthicsMMI & panel interview

A train is rapidly approaching a railway junction. The train's brakes are broken. As of now, the train is set to run over five individuals who are walking on the train track. However, there is a lever in front of you that can divert the train to an adjacent track where only one person is walking. What would you do, considering that the individual(s) walking across whichever track that the train goes towards will not be able to get off the track in time to survive?

302-word sample answer2 ways to stand out1 pitfall1 follow-up

What the interviewer is looking for

Pick an option (pull the lever or don't pull the lever) and discuss your values and thinking clearly.

Sample answer

This scenario is very difficult. I would try my best and pull my composure together in this stressful scenario and try to make the best decision. Of course, I would yell at all the individuals on the train track in advance, with the hope that some may be able to run off. However, knowing that they likely don't have enough time to get off (as mentioned in the question), I would choose to not pull the lever.

There are several important factors to consider here. It is tempting to say that by pulling the lever, I would be saving five lives instead of one. However…

197 more words in the full answer Read the full answer

How to stand out

  • Consider more about the different types of people that may have been on the train track (e.g. a family vs. a grandmother, a country leader vs. five physicians, five strangers vs. your relative, etc.) This could be a follow-up question
  • + 1 more tip in the full answer

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Be careful of crafting a creative option (i.e., something other than pulling the lever vs. not pulling the lever). Sometimes, it is best to simply choose one of the options given in the question because it shows that you can follow clear instructions. However, if you decide to give a creative solution, discuss it after picking one of the straightforward approaches as discussed in the question stem.

Likely follow-up questions

  1. In situations of conflict, how do you determine when to prioritize the needs of the many over the needs of the few?

Interviewers often push further once you answer. Sample answers to each follow-up are in the question bank.

More ethics questions

Browse all medical school interview questions →

Walk into your interview having practised all 627.

Sample answers to every one, follow-up answers and ways to stand out, across the main bank and 51 health policy and topic banks.

Get full access