EthicsMMI & panel interview

You are a third-year medical student on a rotation at a community clinic for the underserved. A patient comes in worried and concerned about a sore throat. Your supervisor, Dr. Gerberoodle, tells you to not worry about the patient because he is a hypochondriac, and to give him a placebo pill (i.e., a sugar pill) to get the patient to leave. What would you do?

295-word sample answer5 ways to stand out1 pitfall1 follow-up

What the interviewer is looking for

Be respectful to your supervisor while discussing why the supervisor's comment was inappropriate. You must also acknowledge why a placebo may be helpful to a patient and show your knowledge in that regard.

Sample answer

In this scenario, my supervisor, Dr. Gerberoodle, has made a concerning comment that can be said to be dismissive toward the patient. I understand that my supervisor may have the patient's best interest in mind—that is, my supervisor may believe that such an approach would be the best way forward to give this patient peace of mind—but this approach may lead to a missed critical diagnosis. Furthermore, giving out placebo medications might be interpreted as deception.

Consequently, I must make sure that the patient gets a complete diagnosis to see if anything is wrong. In this scenario, I would ultimately ask my supervisor…

192 more words in the full answer Read the full answer

How to stand out

  • Discuss what would happen if the patient were to find out that they had been given a placebo
  • + 4 more tips in the full answer

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Be sure to not quickly agree with the doctor, or strongly agree with the doctor's statements—especially the "hypochondriac" part. This could come across as insensitive, unempathetic, and unprofessional.

Likely follow-up questions

  1. What would you consider when deciding whether to speak up or remain silent?

Interviewers often push further once you answer. Sample answers to each follow-up are in the question bank.

More ethics questions

Browse all medical school interview questions →

Walk into your interview having practised all 627.

Sample answers to every one, follow-up answers and ways to stand out, across the main bank and 51 health policy and topic banks.

Get full access