EthicsMMI & panel interview

Two unconscious patients urgently need a lung transplant. One is an elderly woman and another is a young man. However, the young man is a chronic cigarette smoker. Who do you think should get the lung transplant, if only a single lung transplant was available and whichever patient did not receive the transplant would die?

243-word sample answer4 ways to stand out1 pitfall1 follow-up

What the interviewer is looking for

Discuss your thoughts on giving the transplant to either patient before finally coming to a conclusion based on the facts that you have.

Sample answer

In this scenario, it would be tough considering which patient should receive the transplant. Of course, I do not know much about these two patients, but they would likely both have families that care deeply about them and would be disheartened tremendously if their loved one were to pass away.

Before making any decision, I would see if I could talk with any colleagues, superior medical staff, or members of my hospital's ethics board (if there is…

166 more words in the full answer Read the full answer

How to stand out

  • Discuss the topic of the scarcity of certain medical resources like transplant organs
  • + 3 more tips in the full answer

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Avoid not discussing the nuances of the young man's addiction. Also do not forget to show empathy to both patients in your response and not quickly jump to an answer.

Likely follow-up questions

  1. Approximately 30% to 50% of patients with chronic conditions do not follow their prescribed treatment plans, leading to over 125,000 preventable deaths annually in the U.S. alone. What role do you see modern technology playing in solving this issue?

Interviewers often push further once you answer. Sample answers to each follow-up are in the question bank.

More ethics questions

Browse all medical school interview questions →

Walk into your interview having practised all 627.

Sample answers to every one, follow-up answers and ways to stand out, across the main bank and 51 health policy and topic banks.

Get full access